Thursday, 17 January 2013

Cambridge firm and their unqualified health and safety consultant are prosecuted over isocyanate and thrichloroethylene chemical exposure



A Cambridge instrument company and a health and safety consultant have been fined for risking the health of employees from hazardous chemicals. Paint sprayer Adam Coventon, 36, suffered irritation to his eyes, breathing difficulties, headaches and lost the ability to concentrate after working with harmful substances at Prior Scientific Instruments Ltd in Fulbourn. He is now no longer able to work.

Cambridge Magistrates Court heard this week that his job was to prepare and paint small components for scientific instruments, which involved working with chemicals including trichloroethylene, a powerful de-greaser used to clean metal before it is painted, and paints containing isocyanates.  An investigation by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) found that Prior Scientific Instruments did not provide suitable equipment to adequately remove the hazardous vapours from the workplace, especially where items were left to dry.

HSE also found that in addition to inadequate controls, the company failed to provide employees with the necessary health surveillance for workers using hazardous substances. Health surveillance is a key part of ensuring that peoples' health has not been affected by the chemicals they use at work.

The Court was told that between September 2002 and December 2009 the company employed Keith Whiting, trading as KW Consultants, as a health and safety consultant. However, he did not provide suitable information and advice to enable the company to ensure the health and wellbeing of employees.

Prior Scientific Instruments Ltd, of Wilbraham Road, Fulbourn, Cambridge, was fined £9,000 and ordered to pay full costs of £2,852 after pleading guilty to breaching Section 2(1) of the Health & Safety at Work etc Act 1974.

Keith Whiting, trading as KW Consultants, of West Street, Chatteris, Cambridgeshire, was fined £1,500 with costs of £1,000 after pleading guilty to breaching Section 3(2) of the same legislation.

After the hearing HSE Inspector Robert Meardon said "Prior Scientific Instruments failed to ensure the health of its employees because it employed the wrong person to give it health and safety advice. Mr. Whiting's background was in quality control and he did not have adequate knowledge of health and safety for the work going on in this company. He failed to make them aware of the 'do's and don'ts regarding the use of hazardous chemicals. In 2010, the Government commissioned Lord Young to review health and safety laws and among the findings, the inquiry recognised that there were a lot of people claiming to be health and safety experts, who were in fact, not. The national register of health and safety consultants has been set up as a result. All the consultants who are registered are members of a recognised professional body, and it is important that firms seeking to use a consultant choose one from the register."

Adam Coventon's partner, who does not want to be named, said "This whole thing has had a huge effect on our lives, as we have to constantly plan around Adam's symptoms. We all just wish that his remaining symptoms go so that he can once again be fit and strong. "This case highlights the important job the Health and Safety Executive do, and the need for companies to monitor and control chemicals they use so they do not wreck peoples’ lives in the way that ours has been."

Further information and advice about working with chemicals can be found at www.hse.gov.uk/coshh

http://www.hse.gov.uk/press/2013/rnn-e-00313.htm?eban=rss-

Monday, 14 January 2013

Construction health and safety update December 2012 - Learning from London 2012 Olympic Games



London 2012
To round up our construction commentary for 2012, we thought we would highlight the health and safety successes of the London 2012 Olympic Games and point you in the direction of some ideas for implementing similar good practice on your own construction sites.
Health and safety
Building the venues and infrastructure for London 2012 was one of the largest construction projects over undertaken in Europe. Our Stephen Asbury was pleased to have played a small part in recognising the performance of those who built the games infrastructure, as he represented IOSH as a member of the judging panel for the Olympic Delivery Authority (ODA) health, safety and environmental awards in 2009 and 2010.
The main construction project was completed in July 2011, on time, within budget and with an excellent health and safety record, summarised below:
·         Construction workforce on the Olympic Park peaked at 12,500 workers and totalled 46,000 workers over the duration of the project
·         Over 80 million hours worked on the Olympic Park
·         30 periods of one million hours worked without a reportable injury, plus five periods of two million hours and two periods of three million hours
·         Accident frequency rate of 0.16 - well below the average for the UK construction industry and below the national average for all workplaces
·         Fewer than 150 RIDDOR-reportable injuries over the duration of the project
·         No work-related fatalities
The learning legacy
Through the Learning Legacy projectlink to external website, ODA is sharing the knowledge and the lessons learned from the construction of the Olympic Park. This website contains lots of useful information including:
·         Champion products link to external website - standards and guidance that can be adapted to your site
·         Micro reports link to external website - to share solutions and ideas about how health and safety was managed throughout London 2012 projects.
Research
HSE co-operated with the ODA and others on a series of research projects to identify and analyse the health and safety good practice and lessons learned from the London 2012 construction project. The final research report was launched on 30 November 2012 – see Research Report RR955 - Pre-conditioning for success: Characteristics and factors ensuring a safe build for the Olympic Park

Complementing the research reports is a report providing an overview of health and safety on the London 2012 construction programme – see Delivering health and safety on the development of the London 2012 Olympic Park and Athletes’ Village PDF

Key learning message
‘Successful safety management relies on systems and people working together in tandem - neither is sufficient on its own and they rely on each other to achieve the best outcomes.’

Case studies
Health and Safety Executive (HSE) prepared a series of short case studies to demonstrate some of the new and practical solutions used to manage health, safety and welfare during the London 2012 construction project.

Top 10 tips for all construction sites learned from London 2012
Experience from the construction of the Games facilities identified several recurring key themes that emerge as contributing to the good health and safety record during London 2012:
·         Leadership
o    Set the tone on safety: make your expectations clear and lead by example PDF on site - ‘walk the walk, talk the talk’
o    Make sure your workforce is ‘happy, healthy and here’ by giving health risk management equal priority to accident prevention
·         Planning
o    Plan ahead: take time out before starting on a complicated piece of work to consider the risks and work out how to manage them
o    Adapt working practices to manage identified risks PDF: focus on practical measures, there is no need to produce lengthy documents
o    Review and learn: where health and safety failings are identified, look at what went wrong and adapt risk management arrangements to avoid a recurrence
·         Communication
o    Make sure supervisors have the right skills to lead the workforce effectively: as well as technical knowledge, they need good communication skills PDF
o    A short daily activity briefing PDF before work starts will pay dividends for both safety and efficiency
o    Visual standards - posters or photographs illustrating health and safety ‘dos’ and ‘don’ts' PDF - can be a good way of getting messages across
·         Worker engagement
o    Listen to workers and involve them in problem solving: a two-way dialogue is essential if workers are to feel they have a real stake in health and safety
o    Establish a ‘fair blame’ culture on health and safety: if mistakes are made, use them as shared learning points; if rules are flouted, apply sanctions

Cold and hot weather health and safety advice for employers



As the UK seems to be entering a cold snap, we anticipate that employers will need to know about ‘minimum temperature requirements’.  CRS has prepared this briefing note to assist employers to understand the law in this respect, and to know what actions are needed. The article also addresses warm weather actions and the thermal comfort range.
The law on workplace temperature
The regulatory requirements for workplace temperatures are set by the Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992 which replaced the requirements under the Factories Act 1961 and the Offices, Shops and Railways Premises Act 1963. Under the regulations it states that the temperature of indoor workplaces should be reasonable. The Approved Code of Practice defines a reasonable temperature indoors as being normally at least 16°C unless the work involves severe physical work in which case the temperature should be at least 13°C. A thermometer should be provided in workplaces. These regulations only apply to employees; they do not apply to members of the public for example with regard to temperature complaints from customers in a shopping centre or cinema.
Where there are requirement for workrooms to operate at lower temperatures for example for food hygiene purposes you should refer to the specific advice here: chilled food advice.

What employers should do
The Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992 lay down particular requirements for most aspects of the working environment. Regulation 7 deals specifically with the temperature in indoor workplaces and states that ‘During working hours, the temperature in all workplaces inside buildings shall be reasonable.’ However, the application of the regulation depends on the nature of the workplace, such as a bakery, a cold store, an office, a warehouse.
The approved code of practice to the HSW Regulations says ‘The temperature in workrooms should provide reasonable comfort without the need for special clothing. Where such a temperature is impractical because of hot or cold processes, all reasonable steps should be taken to achieve a temperature which is as close as possible to comfortable. 'Workroom' means a room where people normally work for more than short periods. The temperature in workrooms should normally be at least 16 degrees Celsius unless much of the work involves severe physical effort in which case the temperature should be at least 13 degrees Celsius. These temperatures may not, however, ensure reasonable comfort, depending on other factors such as air movement and relative humidity.’
Where the temperature in a workroom would otherwise be uncomfortably high, for example because of hot processes or the design of the building, all reasonable steps should be taken to achieve a reasonably comfortable temperature, for example by:
·         insulating hot plants or pipes;
·         providing air-cooling plant;
·         shading windows;
·         siting workstations away from places subject to radiant heat.
Where a reasonably comfortable temperature cannot be achieved throughout a workroom, local cooling should be provided. In extremely hot weather fans and increased ventilation may be used instead of local cooling.  Where, despite the provision of local cooling, workers are exposed to temperatures which do not give reasonable comfort, suitable protective clothing and rest facilities should be provided. Typical examples of suitable protective clothing would be ice vests, or air/water fed suits. The effectiveness of these PPE systems may be limited if used for extended periods of time with inadequate rest breaks. Where practical there should be systems of work (for example, task rotation) to ensure that the length of time for which individual workers are exposed to uncomfortable temperatures is limited.
PPE
Where personal protective equipment (PPE) is required its weight and ability to prevent sweat evaporating can cause thermal stress. In these situations employers should:
·         Permit work to occur at a slower rate
·         Rotate staff out of this environment on a more frequent basis
·         Allow longer recovery times before permitting re-entry
·         Consider scheduling work to cooler times of the days (early morning, and late afternoon)
·         Periodically revisit your risk assessment to consider if the process could be automated or alternative systems of work/controls can be introduced
·         Re-evaluate your PPE as newer PPE may be lighter and provide improved levels of protection and operator comfort
PPE is intended to protect employees from a primary hazard. People can sometimes wear too much PPE though. Look again at the reasons for the PPE. Can your employees wear less PPE and still have the protection they require? Alternatively, has PPE been employed as a last resort? Other controls instead may reduce or eliminate the need for PPE.
ISO 9920 contains tables that you can use to estimate clothing insulation.
Thermal comfort range
HSE previously defined thermal comfort in the workplace, as: 'An acceptable zone of thermal comfort for most people in the UK lies roughly between 13°C (56°F) and 30°C (86°F), with acceptable temperatures for more strenuous work activities concentrated towards the bottom end of the range, and more sedentary activities towards the higher end.'
In our experience, a ‘thermal comfort policy’ has proven a good idea.  Specifying a range of ‘normally acceptable temperatures’ helps an employer to agree with their workforce what is acceptable.  When temperatures fall below or above this range, the policy can outline what management will do to improve the situation. This is particularly helpful for short periods of cold and hot weather as experienced in the UK, rather than for a process which is routinely associated with temperatures outside this range.
Metabolic heat
The main source of heat gain in the body is the body's own internal heater - metabolic heat. It is generated within the body by the biochemical processes that keep us alive and by the energy we use in physical activity. Measuring metabolic rate is very difficult, requires expensive equipment, a high level of competency and may not be very accurate in an industrial setting.  BS EN 28996 and BS EN ISO 8996 provide a detailed description of how to estimate and/or measure metabolic rate for those interested.
Useful resources
Heat stress in the workplace – what you need to know as an employer http://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/geis1.pdf
Health risks from working in the sun http://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg147.pdf
A short guide to the PPE Regulations http://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg174.pdf